KeyArena

Economic Impact Assessment

 

 

William B. Beyers

Department of Geography

University of Washington

Seattle, WA 98195-3550

beyers@u.washington.edu

 

 

GMA Research Corporation

11808 Northrup Way

Bellevue, WA 98005

gmaresearch@msn.com

 

 

Final February 21, 2006

 

A Report Prepared for Seattle Center

 


Executive Summary

 

            KeyArena had 1.1 million visitors in the year 2005.  These people spent $118 million in relation to their visits to KeyArena.  KeyArena is also home to a number of businesses and is used by many touring groups.  These businesses had revenue from their business activity of $121 million in the year 2005.  Almost $50 million of this revenue came from tickets and admissions to events or performances that took place at KeyArena. 

 

            The spending of KeyArena visitors and businesses created $350 million in business activity, 3,252 jobs, and $102 million in labor income in King County in the year 2005.  In addition, state and local governments received $13.3 million in tax revenues as a result of this business activity at KeyArena.  An estimated 591 people are directly employed by businesses at KeyArena.  Most of these are part-time or seasonal / temporary employees, but 35% (206) have full-time employment.

 

KeyArena is an important tourist destination, with about 43% of its visitors coming from outside King County.  Most of these people make their trips primarily to go to sporting events or concerts at KeyArena.  Their spending, plus the income that businesses at KeyArena receive from sources other than visitors from outside King County, results in economic impacts that would not occur if KeyArena were not located here or if businesses located at KeyArena were not in King County.  These economic impacts are referred to as “new money” impacts.  New money impacts at KeyArena yielded $165 million in business activity, 1,572 jobs, $47 million in labor income, and $6.5 million in tax revenues in the year 2005.  The table below summarizes the total economic impacts and total “new money” impacts of the KeyArena. 

 

Total Economic Impacts

 

Total Economic Output ($millions)

 $    353.3

Employment – No. of Jobs

3,252

Labor Income ($millions)

$102.1

 

 

Tax Impacts ($ millions)

 

State

$7.9

Local

$5.5

Total ($millions)

 $      13.3

New Money Economic Impacts

 

Total Economic Output ($millions)

 $    164.6

Employment – No. of Jobs

1,572

Labor Income ($millions)

$47.3

 

 

Tax Impacts ($ millions)

 

State

$3.7

Local

$2.7

Total ($millions)

 $        6.5

 

 

            A typical group of visitors to KeyArena was composed of two or three people.  Over 98% made their visit to Seattle primarily to visit KeyArena.  They are roughly evenly split between men and women, and encompass all age categories.  They are primarily working full-time or are self-employed, but include retired people, those not working, students, and other classes of people.  They tend to be middle-income people, with household income between $60,000 and $75,000, and come from households with an average of 2.8 persons.  Local visitors to KeyArena typically come to a variety of events at Seattle Center each year, while non-local visitors have a much more targeted visitation pattern.  Typical visitors stay either for 2-3 hours, or for 4-8 hours.  81% of KeyArena visitors are Caucasian, with 19% persons of color, which is in line with the racial makeup of western Washington.  Crowds at sporting events are more diverse than at concerts, with 23% persons of color.

 

            Businesses at KeyArena spend most of their revenues on labor (62%), with 26% of their revenues spent on services, 1% on utilities and telephones, 4% on taxes, and 7% on other goods and services.  About 10% of employees are administrative or clerical, 13% are artistic / professional / technical, 17% are in sales occupations, 10% are employed as contract workers, and 50% have other occupational status.  Contract workers are primarily professional basketball players.

 

It is very clear from the data presented in this report that KeyArena is not only a vibrant location for sports and artistic activities in the City of Seattle, but it is also an important contributor to the economic base of the regional economy.  It generates jobs and income for thousands of people locally, and draws hundreds of thousands of visitors each year from outside the local economy.         

 

This report is primarily based on two surveys.  A survey of 601 groups of patrons was conducted at KeyArena from April 2005 through December 2005.  A survey of businesses at KeyArena was completed in this same time period. 

 

 


 

Table of Contents

 

 

Executive Summary                                                                                         i

Table of Contents                                                                                           iii

Acknowledgements                                                                                        iii

I.          Introduction                                                                                         1

II.         KeyArena Visitor Survey                                                                    2

            Characteristics of KeyArena Visitors                                                 3

            KeyArena Visitor Activities                                                               9

            Visitor Spending                                                                               13

III.       KeyArena Business Survey                                                               19

            Revenue of KeyArena Businesses                                                     19

            Employment                                                                                      20

            Expenses                                                                                           21

IV.       Economic Impact Analysis                                                                26

            Overall Economic Impacts                                                                26

            New Money Impacts                                                                         31

V.        Concluding Comments                                                           33

Appendix I      Patron Questionnaire                                                             34

Appendix II     KeyArena Business Questionnaire                                        38

 

 

Acknowledgements

 

            This study would not have been possible without the help of hundreds of patrons visiting KeyArena.  It would also not have been possible without the help of all of the businesses and resident organizations located at or using KeyArena.  While these three groups contributed the data that made this study possible, the real foundation for making sure that this study happened was the staff of Seattle Center and the Seattle Center Foundation.  In this regard, we must thank Orit Sarfaty (Seattle Center Foundation Staff) and David Heurtel (Seattle Center Staff) for their unending efforts to get the data we needed to complete this project.  We also wish to acknowledge the strong and longstanding support of Tracy Robinson, Executive Director of Seattle Center Foundation, and Virginia Anderson, Director of Seattle Center, for this research project.  Linnea Johnson, a Seattle Center Foundation intern during the summer of 2005, provided valuable assistance in the conduct of this study.  Shelly Yapp and Ned Dunn on Seattle Center staff also provided excellent comments on drafts of this report.

 

 

 


I.          Introduction

 

            The KeyArena is located on the west side of Seattle Center, and it serves as the home for three professional sports teams, as well as the location for concerts, family shows, and other events.  These events attracted 1.1 million people in the year 2005 to KeyArena.  This report documents economic impacts of KeyArena on the King County economy.  It also provides considerable information on visitors to KeyArena, and summary information with regard to the businesses associated with KeyArena.

 

            This report was funded by the Seattle Center, and was undertaken as a part of a larger project focused on the economic impact of the entire Seattle Center[1].  The report is based upon two surveys.  One survey was of visitors to KeyArena.  Section II reports the results of this visitor survey.  GMA Research Corporation interviewed 601 groups of patrons at KeyArena from April 2005 through December 2005.  While the visitor survey’s primary purpose was to provide data for the economic impact assessment, other data were gathered that were of relevance to this research project and of interest to staff at Seattle Center and the Seattle Center Foundation.  The second survey was of sports teams using KeyArena and the Seattle Center’s business activity in support of sports and other events at KeyArena.  These organizations were asked to provide information on their business activity that could be used with the economic impact estimates.  These data were provided directly by these organizations to the consultants.

 

            This report is organized as follows.  First, we present results from the survey of visitors to KeyArena.  Then, we report results from the survey of businesses located on or using KeyArena.  The next section of the report presents results of the economic impact analysis.  This part of the report is divided into two components.  The first section presents aggregate economic impacts, while the second section presents economic impacts associated with “new money”—income that comes from outside the region that would not flow here if the activities at KeyArena were not present in the local economy.  The final section of the report reflects on the results presented here, and includes some suggestions for future research.  Appendix I contains a copy of the questionnaire used for the patron sample, and a tabulation of the sources of survey data.  Appendix II contains a copy of the questionnaire that was answered by sports businesses using KeyArena, as well as by the Seattle Center for its business activity at KeyArena. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

II.        KeyArena Visitor Survey

 

            The questionnaire included in Appendix I was administered by the intercept method at KeyArena.  A sampling plan was developed by GMA Research Corporation that was designed to gather patron surveys from a statistically reliable sample for KeyArena.  The number of interviews conducted at KeyArena are reported in Appendix I.  The interviews taking place at KeyArena were conducted at Sonics, Storm, and Thunderbirds games, as well as at three concerts.  Of the 601 interviews conducted, 596 or 99.2% were considered to contain valid data for the purposes of this study.  The small percentage of surveys not considered to be valid excluded key information needed to calculate visitor spending, such as the number of persons in the group, their primary trip reason, and spending estimates.  Figure 1 indicates the composition of valid interviews by type of event.

 

Figure 1.  Percentage Share of Valid Visitor Surveys by Type of Event

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


N = 596

 

            Attendance at KeyArena used for the purposes of this study was estimated to be 1,104,451 persons.  This number is based on data reported in Appendix I, and it is a combination of estimates provided to the authors of this study for the years 2004 and 2005.  We relied on data for both 2004 and 2005 to compile this report; data provided to the authors indicate modest changes in attendance at KeyArena in these years.  Figure 2 presents estimated attendance by category at KeyArena used in this study.  This figure, when compared to Figure 1, indicates that the surveys of sports patrons were a slightly higher percentage of overall attendance compared to actual attendance.  All interviews of non-sports attendees were conducted at three events, two concerts -- U-2 and Paul McCartney, and one family show, Disney on Ice.  KeyArena is also used for many other events each year in addition to concerts and tenant sporting events.  These events include college graduation ceremonies, business meetings, other sporting events, and family events.  Figure 2 documents estimated attendance shares at these types of events at KeyArena.  The sample of patrons generally is in accordance with this estimate of attendance at KeyArena.  In section II of this report, tables that are labeled “Concerts” are reporting data just for people interviewed at KeyArena Concerts.  In section IV, data labeled “Concerts” includes estimates for KeyArena concerts and other events that took place at KeyArena in the study period as a matter of convenience in the tables. 

 

Figure 2.  Composition of Attendance at KeyArena 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Characteristics of KeyArena Visitors

 

            This section presents a summary of responses describing characteristics of people interviewed, including the size of the groups visiting KeyArena, their primary trip purpose, and a set of responses regarding their socioeconomic characteristics.  The tables in this section of the report include responses from visitors interviewed at sports and concerts at KeyArena as described in Figure 1, and for the entire sample.  The statistics reported as “Total” are not weighted by the relative importance of patron activity in each category of activity, but, rather, represent the composite sample of patrons, unless otherwise noted.

 

            KeyArena patrons were asked if the primary reason for their trip was to attend the performance/exhibition/event at which they were interviewed.  Table 1 presents results from this question, and it indicates that over 98% of trips were made primarily to visit KeyArena.  Clearly, KeyArena is the primary destination for the overwhelming number of its visitors.  Most people indicating that they had some other primary destination were on business or social trips.

 

Table 1.  Responses to “Was the primary reason for your trip today/tonight to attend this performance/exhibition/event?”

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Yes

97.3%

99.6%

98.2%

No

2.7%

0.4%

1.8%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

 

            Table 2 reports the size of the groups interviewed at KeyArena.  It shows the percentage of the groups in each category of visitors by party size.  For example, 10.5% of those interviewed at sports events were alone, while 55.6% of the parties had two people in them.  Table 2 also indicates the mean (average) size of parties, and the size of the median party (group size halfway through the sample).  Generally the mean is higher than the median, because of the skewing effect that relatively few large parties in each category have on the calculation of the mean.  There is little difference in group sizes attending sports and non-sports events at KeyArena.

 

Table 2.  Number of People in Party

# of People

Sports

Concerts

Total

1

10.5%

7.1%

9.2%

2

55.6%

58.9%

56.9%

3

13.2%

12.9%

13.1%

4

13.4%

11.6%

12.8%

5

2.4%

2.2%

2.3%

6

1.9%

4.0%

2.7%

7+

3.0%

3.1%

3.0%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

Mean

2.74

2.72

2.73

Median

2

2

2

N

372

224

596

 

            The visitors to KeyArena were asked to identify their gender and age, and to also report the gender and age of up to seven other people in their party.  Table 3 presents a summary of responses to this question regarding gender.  Overall, slightly more females were in visitor groups to KeyArena than males in the sample.  When weighted by attendance, this percentage becomes 48.9% male, and 51.1% female.

 

Table 3.  Gender of KeyArena Patrons In Sample

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Male

51.3%

44.6%

48.7%

Female

48.7%

55.4%

51.3%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

907

574

1,481

 

            Each person responding to the question regarding age and gender was asked to indicate their age and the age of each of up to seven additional persons in their group.  Table 4 presents the results of an analysis of responses to this question.  Somewhat fewer of those interviewed revealed their age compared to their gender (N (number) on age = 1,394 versus N = 1,481 on gender), about 85% and 90% of the total number of people included in the valid sample, respectively.  The data in Table 4 indicate a slightly varying mean age of visitors to KeyArena sports and concerts events.  People in the entire sample had a mean age in their thirties, while the mean age of adults (those 18 years or older) was 40 at sports events and 39 at concerts. 

 

   Table 4.  Age Distribution of KeyArena Patrons In Sample

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Up to 11

7.5%

12.9%

9.5%

12 to 17

5.6%

5.4%

5.5%

18 to 24

10.9%

7.3%

9.5%

25 to 34

18.9%

21.1%

19.7%

35 to 44

26.3%

26.4%

26.3%

45 to 54

17.3%

20.6%

18.6%

55 to 64

10.7%

5.8%

8.8%

65+

2.8%

0.6%

1.9%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

859

535

1394

 

 

 

 

Mean

36

34

35

Mean Adults

18+ Years

40

39

40

 

            People responding to the visitor questionnaire were asked to indicate their highest level of educational attainment.  Table 5 presents results from this question.  About one-third of the respondents had up to a high school degree, another twenty percent had some college, while over 44% indicated that they had a bachelors or post-baccalaureate degree.  It is likely that some respondents checking postgraduate degree should have checked four year college / university degree, as the layout of the questionnaire was not as clear as it could have been for this question. 

 

Table 5.  Educational Attainment of Interviewed KeyArena Patrons

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Some High School

3.0%

0.9%

2.2%

High School Graduate

35.4%

34.5%

35.1%

Some College

19.2%

16.8%

18.3%

Four-year College/University Degree

11.0%

13.6%

12.0%

Postgraduate Degree

31.3%

34.1%

32.4%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

364

220

584

 

 

            Respondents were asked to identify their occupation, using the categories listed in Table 6.  These are not occupation categories typically used that define positions by type of work (such as executive/managerial, professional/technical, sales, clerical, or blue collar), but rather are another grouping deemed appropriate for this study.  It is clear that most respondents to this question were either working full-time or were self-employed. 

 

Table 6.  Occupation of Persons Interviewed at the KeyArena

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Working full-time

66.4%

68.5%

67.2%

Homemaker

2.5%

2.7%

2.6%

Retired

7.9%

3.2%

6.1%

Working part-time

4.6%

6.3%

5.3%

Military

2.2%

1.8%

2.0%

Not Employed

2.5%

0.5%

1.7%

Self Employed

8.7%

8.6%

8.7%

Student

3.6%

3.6%

3.6%

Other

1.6%

5.0%

2.9%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

366

222

588

 

            Visitors to KeyArena come from a wide variety of geographic locations, as reported in Table 7.  Local visitors (people living in King County) account for the largest share of sports patrons, but most patrons at KeyArena concerts were from outside King County.  Of the King County residents in the sample, 34% were from Seattle zip-codes, while 66% were from other parts of King County.  The total estimated visitation in Table 7 and Figure 3 is based on the estimated number of visitors to categories used to estimate the total number of KeyArena visitors.

 

Table 7.  Origin of KeyArena Visitors

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

King County

64.4%

42.9%

56.5%

Other Washington State

28.1%

39.6%

32.3%

Out of State

7.5%

17.5%

11.2%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

360

212

572

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Figure 3.  Origin of KeyArena Visitors

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


            Patrons were asked to indicate how many people lived in their household, and Table 8 reports results from this question.  Households in the sample have a somewhat smaller size than the size of groups interviewed (see data in Table 2), implying that in many instances visitors came with friends or relatives to KeyArena on their trips.  Median and mean household sizes are lower for sports than concert patrons.

 

Table 8.  Household Size of KeyArena Visitor Groups

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

1

14.4%

9.3%

12.5%

2

42.1%

36.7%

40.1%

3

17.5%

22.8%

19.5%

4

17.5%

23.3%

19.7%

5

6.5%

5.6%

6.2%

6

0.8%

1.4%

1.1%

7 to 10

1.1%

0.9%

1.1%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

 

 

 

 

Mean

2.69

2.87

2.76

Median

2

3

2

N

354

215

569

 

            The ethnicity of those interviewed is reported in Table 9.  This table indicates that most of those attending KeyArena activities are Caucasian.  These data are for the person responding to the survey, so their group might have had different ethnic composition.  Sports events attract a more diverse crowd than KeyArena concerts.

 

Table 9.  Ethnicity of Interviewed KeyArena Patrons

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Caucasian

77.1%

88.6%

81.4%

Asian, Pacific Islander

9.6%

3.8%

7.4%

Native American

3.1%

0.5%

2.1%

Hispanic, Latin

3.1%

5.2%

3.9%

African American

7.1%

1.9%

5.1%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

353

211

564

 

            The final question regarding characteristics of KeyArena visitors was related to their household income.  An encouraging 90% of the valid sample answered this sensitive question, one that typically gets a smaller response rate than other eco-demographic questions.  The results for this question are reported in Table 10.  These data record a very similar distribution of income for KeyArena sports and concerts patrons.  The median household income is in the $60,000-$74,999 category.  The King County median household income was estimated to be $59,718 in 2005[2].  However, 43% of KeyArena visitors are from outside King County, and it is beyond the resources of this study to analyze the comparative income distribution of the communities from which these visitors have come, and the incomes reported in this study.  Overall, it appears as though incomes are predominantly in the “middle income” group for visitors to KeyArena.

 

Table 10.  Household Income of KeyArena Patrons

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Under $20,000

5.9%

5.0%

5.6%

$20,000 to $39,999

12.5%

12.5%

12.5%

$40,000 to $59,999

17.2%

16.5%

16.9%

$60,000 to $74,999

15.4%

17.5%

16.2%

$75,000 to $99,999

19.9%

18.5%

19.4%

$100,000 to $124,999

12.8%

13.0%

12.8%

$125,000 to $249,999

12.2%

11.5%

11.9%

Over $250,000

4.2%

5.5%

4.7%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

337

200

537

 

Section Summary

            KeyArena sports and concert visitors are well represented in the survey of visitors reported in this section.  KeyArena was the primary reason for most of their trips.  Two person groups were most common, but there are many individuals making KeyArena trips and also many groups involving more than two people.  The gender of visitors is roughly evenly split between men and women.  The typical visitor is in their thirties, but all ages are found in KeyArena visitors.  People surveyed were generally well-educated, with over 44% having at least a bachelors degree, and 63% having at least some college.  Over 75% of those interviewed were working full- or part-time, or were self-employed.  About 6% were retired, and the balance was made up of either homemakers, persons unemployed, or students.  Over 43% of the visitors to KeyArena were from outside King County; most of these came from elsewhere in Washington State (32%), while 11% came from out-of-state.  Of the King County residents, 34% reported Seattle zip-codes.  The household size of the average group of visitors was slightly less than three persons.  Most people interviewed were Caucasian (81%), and median household income was between $60,000 and $75,000.

 

 

KeyArena Visitor Activities

 

            This section reports results of questions related to activity at Seattle Center by visitors to KeyArena.  It reports on their participation in various activities at Seattle Center on the trip at which they were interviewed, as well as their activity over the course of a year.

 

            Many people visiting KeyArena also participate in other activities at Seattle Center on their trip.  In many cases these other activities are also counted by Seattle Center as visits, such as a person attending a concert at KeyArena who rode the monorail to Seattle Center would be counted as attending the KeyArena, and also counted for their monorail ride.  KeyArena patrons were asked to identify these activities with regard to the trip on which they were interviewed.  Table 11 reports results of this question.  This table indicates that almost all of those interviewed at a sports event or a concert replied that they were attending these activities.  This table also indicates that the average patron also participated in an average of one other activity, most commonly engaging in dining and shopping, or visiting an attraction or museum at Seattle Center.  It should be noted that some of these other activities would be subject to tickets or admission fees (such as visiting the Space Needle or going to EMP).

 

Table 11.  Activities Participated in on Visits to KeyArena (columns are the percentages of people interviewed at the type of event who said they engaged in the activities listed in the rows)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Sports

99.5%

0.9%

62.4%

Arts – Including Concerts

8.6%

99.6%

42.8%

Dining & Shopping

27.7%

33.9%

30.0%

Attractions & Museums

30.1%

28.1%

29.4%

Major Festivals

0.3%

0.4%

0.3%

Seattle Center Public Programs

2.4%

6.3%

3.9%

Other-Campus

10.8%

12.1%

11.2%

Other 

16.9%

25.4%

20.1%

Total Citations

196.2%

206.7%

200.2%

 

 

 

 

Sample Size

372

224

596

 

KeyArena patrons were asked to identify how frequently they came to Seattle Center to attend five categories of activity: ticketed sports events, ticketed cultural/arts performances/exhibits, free cultural/arts/performances/exhibits, festivals, and community gatherings.  The frequency of answers to these questions is presented in Tables 12A-12E.  Each table shows the percentage down a column of those interviewed at a particular type of activity indicating their frequency of participation in the activity on the title of the table.  For example, regarding coming to a ticketed sports event, of those interviewed at a KeyArena sports event, 22.8% indicated that they came weekly to a sports event at Seattle Center, 36.0% said they came once or more per month, 28.5% said they came three or four times each year, 5.1% came once a year, 6.5% came less than once per year, 0.5% said that they never came to a Seattle Center sports event, and 0.5% did not respond to this question.  With regard to this same question, 0.4% of the people interviewed at a KeyArena concert indicated they came to a Seattle Center ticketed sports event weekly, while 19.6% reported that they never came to such an event.  There is a clear tendency for some non-response to this set of questions by people interviewed at an activity different than the focus of the question.  However, it is evident that most people interviewed indicated that they had some participation in ticketed sports events, ticketed arts events, free arts events, and festivals on an annual basis.  The responses were much lower with regard to coming to community gatherings at Seattle Center.

 

Table 12A.  Ticketed Sports Events (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Weekly

22.8%

0.4%

14.4%

Once or More per Month

36.0%

6.7%

25.0%

3 or 4 Times per Year

28.5%

29.9%

29.0%

Once a Year

5.1%

13.4%

8.2%

Less than Once a Year

6.5%

19.2%

11.2%

Never

0.5%

19.6%

7.7%

No response

0.5%

10.7%

4.4%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

 

 

Table 12B.  Ticketed Cultural Arts/Performance (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Weekly

0.5%

0.4%

0.5%

Once or More per Month

4.6%

2.2%

3.7%

3 or 4 Times per Year

23.1%

29.9%

25.7%

Once a Year

21.0%

24.6%

22.3%

Less than Once a Year

15.3%

28.1%

20.1%

Never

13.4%

6.3%

10.7%

No response

22.0%

8.5%

16.9%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

 

 

Table 12C.  Free Cultural Arts Performance / Exhibits (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Weekly

0.3%

0.4%

0.3%

Once or More per Month

5.6%

2.7%

4.5%

3 or 4 Times per Year

21.2%

17.9%

20.0%

Once a Year

20.4%

17.4%

19.3%

Less than Once a Year

14.2%

14.3%

14.3%

Never

16.7%

25.9%

20.1%

No response

21.5%

21.4%

21.5%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

Table 12D.  Festivals (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Weekly

0.0%

0.0%

0.0%

Once or More per Month

3.2%

2.7%

3.0%

3 or 4 Times per Year

26.3%

21.4%

24.5%

Once a Year

29.6%

23.7%

27.3%

Less than Once a Year

11.0%

13.4%

11.9%

Never

12.9%

21.9%

16.3%

No response

16.9%

17.0%

16.9%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

 

Table 12E.  Community Gatherings

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Weekly

0.0%

0.0%

0.0%

Once or More per Month

1.9%

1.8%

1.8%

3 or 4 Times per Year

9.7%

4.9%

7.9%

Once a Year

14.0%

10.7%

12.8%

Less than Once a Year

15.9%

15.6%

15.8%

Never

30.6%

39.3%

33.9%

No response

28.0%

27.7%

27.9%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

372

224

596

 

People were asked how long they expected to stay at Seattle Center on their current visit to KeyArena.  Results for this question are presented in Table 13.  This table indicates that most people expected to be at the Seattle Center for either two or three hours, or four to eight hours.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 13.  How Long People Expected to Stay on Their Visit Today (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

One Hour

0.3%

0.0%

0.2%

2-3 Hours

46.5%

31.7%

40.9%

4-8 Hours

47.8%

55.8%

50.8%

Over 8 Hours

3.8%

11.2%

6.5%

No response

1.6%

1.3%

1.5%

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

 

            KeyArena visitors were also asked how many times each year they came to Seattle Center.  Table 14 reports responses to this question, which display an enormous range of reported frequencies of visits.  Although all of these people were interviewed at KeyArena, some of them indicated making zero visits per year.  People interviewed at KeyArena Concerts reported an average of four Seattle Center visits annually, while those interviewed at KeyArena sports events reported a much higher average attendance—twelve trips per year.  These averages correspond well to reports of attendance at ticketed sports events and ticketed cultural arts/performance contained in Tables 12A and 12B.

 

Table 14.  Number of Times Visitors Come to the Seattle Center per Year (% down column)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

0

0.9%

5.4%

2.6%

1

5.2%

15.3%

9.0%

2

4.3%

12.9%

7.5%

3

7.8%

13.9%

10.1%

4

6.4%

9.9%

7.7%

5

6.4%

9.4%

7.5%

6

4.6%

8.4%

6.0%

7 to 10

12.8%

12.4%

12.6%

11 to 15

12.2%

5.9%

9.9%

16 to 25

16.8%

3.5%

11.9%

26 to 50

19.7%

1.0%

12.8%

51 to 100

2.0%

1.0%

1.6%

101 to 200

0.6%

1.0%

0.7%

300

0.3%

0.0%

0.2%

Average

12

4

6

Total

100.0%

100.0%

100.0%

N

345

202

547

 

            Section Summary

            KeyArena visitors typically engage in more than one Seattle Center activity on their visits to KeyArena.  The average visitor engages in two types of activity on their KeyArena/Seattle Center visit, typically an admission to the KeyArena event at which they were interviewed, along with dining, shopping, or a visit to attractions and museums.  KeyArena patrons’ frequency of use of Seattle Center varies significantly, with the typical sports patron coming to the Seattle Center twelve times per year, while the typical concert patron reported four trips per year.  Some people come to Seattle Center everyday.  Most KeyArena visitors come to ticketed sports and arts events, as well as free arts events and festivals annually, but their frequency of attendance is highly variable.  Most KeyArena visitors stay at Seattle Center for between two and eight hours on their visit.

 

 

 

Visitor Spending

 

            KeyArena visitors were asked to record their estimated expenditures related to their trip to KeyArena.  Patrons were asked to report only those expenditures that they would attribute to attending the activity that was their destination on the day of the interview.  The few patrons whose primary trip reason was not to visit KeyArena often recorded costs for airplane travel, hotels, and automobile travel that were very high, given what they were doing at KeyArena.  Expenditures that did not appear attributable to the KeyArena visit were removed from the analysis of visitor spending.  Table 15 reports average expenditures per person for the valid sample.  The reported expenditures for tickets / admissions for concerts is considerably above the value for sports.  This high reported cost for KeyArena concert tickets was a result of interviews conducted at two concerts with ticket costs well above the average for KeyArena concerts, as will be discussed below.

 

Table 15.  Average Expenditures Per Person in Sample

 

Sports

Concerts

Composite

Tickets/Admissions

$45.40

$108.72

$70.18

Souvenirs and gifts

7.80

15.84

10.95

Parking fees

3.90

2.73

3.44

Bus/ferry/taxi

0.86

1.22

1.00

Auto travel

5.34

5.97

5.59

Food / beverages

before or after event

11.85

12.74

12.20

Food / beverages

at the event

9.05

5.49

7.66

Entertainment

2.31

3.10

2.62

Lodging /

Accommodations

2.31

17.66

8.31

Air travel

3.29

19.19

9.51

Child care

0.63

0.30

0.50

Other

3.63

4.74

4.07

Total

$96.37

$197.71

$136.03

N

944

607

1,551

 

            Spending by visitors to the KeyArena varies by region of origin.  Table 16 reports average expenditures reported by visitors in the valid sample, divided into visitors from King County, from elsewhere in Washington State, and from Out of State.  For those visitors traveling from outside King County costs for travel, food and beverages, and lodging / accommodations rise significantly.  Spending also increases on souvenirs and entertainment for those traveling from outside King County.

 

Table 16.  Spending Per Capita by Region of Origin in Sample

 

King County

Other Washington

Out of State

Tickets/Admissions

$57.63

$81.61

$88.46

Souvenirs and gifts

8.59

12.57

17.04

Parking fees

3.78

3.02

2.99

Bus/ferry/taxi

0.52

0.98

2.87

Auto travel

4.09

5.06

11.33

Food / beverages

before or after event

8.95

15.83

15.52

Food / beverages

at the event

7.02

7.32

12.78

Entertainment

1.96

3.23

3.50

Lodging /

Accommodations

0.35

5.12

29.58

Air travel

0.96

3.09

61.92

Child care

0.70

0.27

0.25

Other

4.08

2.37

7.21

Total

$98.64

$140.47

$253.44

 

 

It was necessary to adjust reported spending on KeyArena concert admissions to have these values be in accord with data obtained from Seattle Center on admissions paid for KeyArena concerts and other non-professional sports events.  Seattle Center records report for KeyArena Concerts and other non-professional sports events $14.9 million in admissions receipts in 2005, and $15.7 million in 2004 (including NCAA playoffs), very similar statistics. 

 

The ticket spending reported for the U-2 and Paul McCartney concerts were much higher than the average KeyArena concert.  The average patron interviewed at the U2 concert reported spending $124.49 on tickets, while for the Paul McCartney show this figure was $205.55.  Data provided by the Seattle Center showed 2004 receipts per capita for events other than concerts to be $12.91.  Total admissions for 2004 were $15.7 million.  Using $12.91 as the average admissions expenditure for non-concert events, and an estimated 149,651 admissions to events other than concerts, yields an estimated expenditure of $1.93 million on tickets/admissions.  The balance of revenue for KeyArena concerts was estimated to be $13.78 million, which would imply an average ticket cost of $58.13 given the estimated attendance of 237,052.  This is consistent with Figure 4, which shows the number of concerts and their ticket prices in 2004.  An average ticket cost of $58.13 was used in the estimate of total concert ticket outlays, rather than the average from the survey data.

 

Figure 4.  Distribution of KeyArena Concerts Ticket Prices in 2004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


            KeyArena sports and arts visitors engaged in activities besides those taking place in KeyArena that were subject to admissions or ticket expenditures.  These expenditures would have been reported along with their sports or concert ticket costs in the survey of visitors, given how this question was worded.  Some 35% of the concert patrons checked some other activity that would have had a ticket/admission cost, while 41% of those interviewed at sports events reported these activities.  We do not know exactly how much this spending was beyond the KeyArena tickets.  This is other activity at the Seattle Center that has an economic impact, and needs to be included in this analysis.  Table 17 presents a listing of activities cited by KeyArena sports and concert patrons subject to admissions or tickets in venues outside where they were interviewed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 17.  Distribution of KeyArena Patrons citations of things subject to admissions/tickets

 

Sports

# Citations

% of Total

Concerts # Citations

% of Total

Arts

32

8.6%

0

0.0%

Pacific Science Center

26

7.0%

8

3.6%

Sports

0

0.0%

2

0.9%

Festivals

9

2.4%

14

6.3%

Fun Forest

16

4.3%

4

1.8%

Monorail

19

5.1%

8

3.6%

Museums

16

4.3%

15

6.7%

Space Needle

35

9.4%

28

12.5%

Total

153

41.1%

79

35.3%

 

            Using the average expenditures reported in the Seattle Center report for admissions/tickets at these sites yields an average of $4.14 for additional admissions by those attending KeyArena concerts[3].  For those interviewed at a sports event, the mean was $9.73.  Excepting the citations for arts, the mean for those interviewed at a sports event is $3.65, very close to the value for concerts.  An analysis of the 32 cases where sports patrons checked arts, finds that reported ticket costs in only 3 of these cases are large enough to cover the sports event as well as an arts event with an average ticket price for all Seattle Center arts events.  Thus, it seems reasonable to not include in tickets/admissions an allowance for arts spending by sports patrons.  Based on this analysis, if the concerts frequency for arts is accurate (solution to an overall estimated Seattle Center attendance model suggests that it is), then of the $44.94 in tickets/admissions reported by sports fans, $41.29 is for sports admissions, and the balance on other admissions.  Using the estimate of $58.13 for KeyArena concerts, an additional $4.14 was spent on average by these concertgoers, or an average of $62.27.

 

            We do not have any sample data for people attending the other events identified in Figure 2.  We have assumed that their spending is the same as KeyArena concert attendees, except for tickets/admissions.  This would make their ticket/admission outlays to be $17.06 ($12.91 + $4.14).  These values have been used to estimate the total spending in Table 19.  For sports this is $2.61 million in other tickets/admissions, and for concerts it is $1.6 million.  This spending has been treated as a purchase from the sector 37 in the Input/Output model (arts, recreation, and accommodations)[4].

 

            The average estimated expenditures per visitor after these adjustments are reported in Table 18.  The average outlays reported for concerts is for both KeyArena concerts as well as other events taking place at KeyArena.  These expenditure estimates were used to calculate total KeyArena visitor expenditures.  These data have also been weighted to take into account the estimated number of patrons by region of origin.  The average spending by sports fans differs slightly from the Seattle Center economic impact assessment, as that study included some responses that did not report their region of origin, while the present study is based on responses with region of origin data.

 

Table 18.  Adjusted Average Expenditures Used in Modeling, weighted by attendance and shares by region of origin and concerts/other KeyArena events

 

Sports

Concerts

Composite

Tickets/Admissions

$45.40

$44.77

$45.18

Souvenirs and gifts

7.80

17.51

11.20

Parking fees

3.90

2.90

3.55

Bus/ferry/taxi

0.86

1.20

0.98

Auto travel

5.34

4.96

5.21

Food / beverages

before or after event

11.85

14.45

12.76

Food / beverages

at the event

9.05

5.92

7.95

Entertainment

2.31

2.83

2.49

Lodging /

Accommodations

2.31

9.98

4.99

Air travel

3.29

17.59

8.30

Child care

0.63

0.48

0.58

Other

3.63

4.47

3.93

Total

$96.37

$127.05

$107.11

 

            Total spending by KeyArena patrons was estimated by multiplying estimated attendance figures by the values in Table 18, to obtain total patron outlays.  These estimates are reported in Table 19.  It should be noted that tables beginning with Table 19 are expressed in millions of dollars.  This table reports total spending by KeyArena sports visitors of $69 million, and spending by KeyArena concert and other visitors of $49 million, or a total of $118 million.  Well over half of this spending ($68 million) is for goods and services other than tickets / admissions to KeyArena events.  It should be noted that the total for sports here is slightly different than in the Seattle Center report, because we accounted for some of the sports participation in the Seattle Center report from people originating in other Seattle Center venues.  Figures in this report are slightly higher for sports ($69.17 million), versus $65.86 million in the Seattle Center report.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 19.  Total KeyArena Visitor Expenditures ($ millions)

 

Sports

Concerts

Total

Tickets/Admissions

$32.58M

$17.31M

$49.90M

Souvenirs and gifts

5.60

6.77

12.37

Parking fees

2.80

1.12

3.92

Bus/ferry/taxi

0.61

0.46

1.08

Auto travel

3.83

1.92

5.75

Food / beverages

before or after event

8.51

5.59

14.09

Food / beverages

at the event

6.50

2.29

8.79

Entertainment

1.66

1.09

2.75

Lodging /

Accommodations

1.66

3.86

5.52

Air travel

2.36

6.80

9.17

Child care

0.45

0.19

0.64

Other

2.61

1.73

4.34

Total

$69.17M

$49.13M

$118.30M


 

 

 


III.       KeyArena Business Survey

 

            A survey was undertaken of KeyArena sports businesses, and of Seattle Center operations that support events at KeyArena.  A copy of this survey is found in Appendix II.  Data on KeyArena Concerts and other events was provided to the authors by Seattle Center.  This data included summaries of settlement sheets with KeyArena concert presenters and promoters, as well as data gathered by Seattle Center in relation to these concerts and other events.  Due to confidentiality promises to businesses participating in this study, we are not providing detailed tables by type of business activity in this section of this report.

 

Revenue of KeyArena Businesses

 

            It is estimated that total revenue associated with sports, concerts and other activities at KeyArena, and the support services provided by Seattle Center, was $121.82 million in the year 2005.  It is estimated that $48.26 million of this was “new money,” that is revenue that came to these businesses from sources located outside King County.  This includes the estimated value of ticket purchases made by people from outside King County, plus other revenue of these businesses.  The estimated new money was 39.6% of total revenues.  Figure 5 indicates the percentage of new money by type of business activity at KeyArena. 

 

Figure 5.  KeyArena New Money Percentages

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Employment

 

            Businesses using and servicing KeyArena provide employment for nearly 600 people, as reported in Table 20 and Figure 6.  Administrative and clerical employees account for 10% of this total, while artistic/professional/technical employees account for 13%, and sales employees 17% of total employment.  Most employment is in the category “other personnel”, and these are largely part-time or seasonal/temporary workers, as reported below.  Contract employees account for 10% of total employment.  It should be noted that these figures exclude people employed by promoters and presenters to help set up, stage, and take down KeyArena concerts and other non-sports events.  Expenditures for the work that these people undertake are included in the economic impact analysis, and indirectly their employment level is estimated in the economic impact analysis. 

 

Table 20.  Employment Composition of KeyArena Activities

Administrative / Clerical

58

Artistic / Professional / Technical

75

Sales

100

Other Personnel

299

Contract Employees

59

Total

591

 

 

 

Figure 6.  Composition of Employment by Occupation

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


            The distribution of KeyArena employment by work tenure is reported in Table 21 and Figure 7.  Full-time employment is provided for over one-third of KeyArena employees, while almost two-thirds of these people work seasonally or as temporary employees.  Just 1% of KeyArena employees are part-time.

 

Table 21.  Full Time, Part Time, and Seasonal/Temporary Employment

Full Time

206

Part Time

7

Seasonal/Temporary

378

Total

591

 

Figure 7.  Composition of Employment by Work Tenure

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Expenses

 

            The expenditures of KeyArena businesses are reported in Table 22 and Figure 8.  Contract employees (mostly but not all are professional sports contract employees) are the largest share of expenses (52%), followed by services (26%).  Wage and salary payments represent 10% of expenses, while other goods and services account for 7%, taxes for 4%, and utilities and telephone for 1% of expenses.

 

 

 

Table 22.  Major Expense Categories ($ millions)

Wages & Salaries

$13.00M

Contract Employees

64.70

Services

32.54

Utilities & Telephone

1.16

Other Goods & Services

8.67

Taxes

4.77

Total Expenses

$124.83M

 

Figure 8.  Composition of Expenses

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


            The largest share of expenses of KeyArena businesses are for labor, as reported in Table 22 and Figure 8.  Table 23 reports the composition of earnings for employees and contract personnel.  Employee costs are relatively evenly divided between administrative/clerical, artistic/professional/technical, sales, and other employees.  Contract personnel earnings are dominated by payments to artistic / professional / technical personnel.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 23.  Earnings by Occupation ($ Millions)

Employees:

Administrative / Clerical

$3.66

Artistic / Professional / Technical

3.30

Sales

3.68

Other Personnel

2.36

 

 

Contract Personnel:

Administrative / Clerical

0.00

Artistic / Professional / Technical

64.25

Sales

0.00

Other Personnel

0.44

 

 

Total

$77.69

 

            The non-employee expenses categories reported in Table 22 and Figure 8 are reported in more detail in Tables 24 through 27.  Table 24 presents detailed information on service expenditures.  In addition to reporting the dollar amount of spending for these services, this table reports the share of total services outlays by expenditure category, and the share of the spending that accrues to King County businesses.  The largest expenditure categories are for marketing, transportation, and for “other” services.  The “other services” category includes payments made to promoters and performing groups at KeyArena; these payments were about $10 million and predominantly non-local.  Most of the service purchases reported in Table 24 were made locally, while several categories associated with travel by KeyArena businesses had lower local spending (transportation, lodging, purchased food & beverage services).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 24.  Service Expenditures ($ millions)

 

 

% of Services

% in

King County

Marketing

$7.43

22.8%

89.9%

Press & public relations

0.69

2.1%

100.0%

Photographic/art services

0.04

0.1%

52.9%

Banking

0.46

1.4%

100.0%

Insurance

0.72

2.2%

100.0%

Professional services

1.85

5.7%

95.2%

Janitorial/protective

0.07

0.2%

100.0%

Transportation

3.18

9.8%

51.7%

Lodging

0.44

1.3%

52.5%

Purchased food/beverage services

0.84

2.6%

77.7%

Set/costume/exhibit rental

0.26

0.8%

100.0%

Equipment rental

0.34

1.0%

100.0%

Hall Rental (Incl. payments to Seattle Center)

3.13

9.6%

100.0%

Seattle Center Event Services

1.63

5.0%

100.0%

Seattle Center Labor Reimbursement

0.10

0.3%

100.0%

Office and work space rental

0.94

2.9%

100.0%

Royalties

0.00

0.0%

 

Other Services

10.43

32.0%

2.7%

Total

$32.54

100.0%

60.2%

 

            Table 25 reports spending for telephone and utilities.  This table reports that about half of these outlays were for utilities, while the balance was split between postage and telephone & cable services.  Most of these outlays were also made in King County.

 

Table 25.  Telephone and Utility Expenditures  ($ millions)

 

 

% of Total

% in King County

Telephone & cable services

$0.44M

37.5%

98.3%

Postage

0.17

15.0%

100.0%

Other Utilities

0.55

47.5%

100.0%

Total

$1.16M

100.0%

99.4%

 

            KeyArena businesses incurred about 7% of their total costs on other goods and services, whose composition is reported in Table 26.  This table indicates a somewhat higher level of purchase outside the local area than for other expenditure categories, largely in relation to the “other goods and services” category.  This category includes merchandise being sold by KeyArena businesses, or specialized services that did not fit other categories in the questionnaire.

 

 

 

 

Table 26.  Other Goods and Service Expenditures ($ millions)

 

 

% of Total

% in King County

Printing

$0.83M

9.6%

85.7%

Exhibit/set materials

0.00

0.0%

0.0%

Production Materials

1.46

16.8%

50.4%

Supplies

0.40

4.6%

83.3%

Maintenance

0.50

5.8%

82.9%

Other

5.48

63.3%

51.2%

Total

$8.67M

100.0%

57.6%

 

            KeyArena businesses reported payments of about $4.8 million in taxes, as reported in Table 27.  The largest of these reported taxes was City of Seattle admissions tax, followed by the business and occupation tax, and then sales taxes. 

 

Table 27.  Tax Payments ($ millions)

 

 

% of Total

% in King County

Sales Tax

$0.22M

4.6%

77.0%

B&O Tax

2.16

45.2%

85.4%

Property Tax

0.15

3.1%

100.0%

City Admissions Tax

2.24

46.9%

100.0%

Other Taxes

0.01

0.2%

100.0%

 

$4.77M

100.0%

92.4%

 

 


IV.       Economic Impact Analysis

 

            The results of the surveys of KeyArena visitors and KeyArena businesses were brought together to calculate economic impacts through use of an Input/Output model.  The model used in this analysis is a model of the King County economy, and it is driven by two sets of data.  First, the direct values of sales, employment, labor income, and other value added for KeyArena businesses as described in Section III of this report were entered as final demands.  The direct purchases in the regional economy constitute the second set of data entering this model, and these data are included in Table 28. 

            Two estimates of economic impact are presented in this section of the report.  The first is an overall estimate of economic impacts, based on the gross spending of KeyArena visitors and businesses.  The second estimate is referred to as a “new money” estimate, and it is based on the dollars spent by visitors coming from outside King County, and on the revenue generated by KeyArena businesses from income sources located outside King County.  The gross impact estimate documents the current overall economic impact of KeyArena, but it includes discretionary spending by local residents that could be shifted to other activities.  While if such a shift were to occur, it is likely that the economic impacts of a different spending pattern by local residents would be different than current impacts, it is also likely that the total economic impacts would not be markedly different.  The second estimate (“new money”) provides an estimate of the contribution of KeyArena to the economic base of King County.  This estimate can be interpreted as the magnitude of the loss to the King County economy if business activity now taking place at KeyArena were not located here.

 

Overall Economic Impacts

 

The data in Table 28 represent conversion of the consumer expenditure categories used in the KeyArena visitor survey into Input/Output model sectors, with appropriate adjustments for non-King County production being eliminated from these purchase estimates.  The data in Table 28 also contains estimates of purchases by Input/Output sector of KeyArena businesses, as reported in Tables 22, 24, 25, and 26.  The sum of these purchases is less than the sum of purchases reported for KeyArena businesses and KeyArena visitors because in many cases purchases were made of goods or services not produced in King County.  The questionnaire included in Appendix II asked respondents to indicate the share of their expenditures made in King County.  Thus, Table 28 represents net estimates of direct purchases made in King County, plus purchases of labor that are included elsewhere in the Input/Output model.  It should be noted that these estimates have been made to avoid “double counting” of expenditures.  For example, ticket / admissions paid to KeyArena businesses are excluded from the economic impact estimates, while the expenditures that the organizations included in the study made as a result of visits by KeyArena patrons are included.  Payments to Seattle Center for services rendered by various KeyArena presenters have been excluded as purchases, while the expenditures of Seattle Center in relation to these services are included in this analysis.

 

 

Table 28.  King County First-Round Purchases ($ millions)

 

Visitors

Businesses

Total

 1  Crop production

 

 

0

 2  Animal production

 

 

0

 3  Forestry and fishing

 

 

0

 4  Logging

 

 

0

 5  Mining

 

 

0

 6  Electric utilities

 

$0.342M

$0.342M

 7  Gas utilities

 

0.146

0.146

 8  Other utilities

 

0.065

0.065

 9  Construction

 

0.414

0.414

10  Food manufacturing

 

 

0

11  Textiles and apparel

 

 

0

12  Wood product manufacturing

 

 

0

13  Paper manufacturing

 

 

0

14  Printing

 

0.713

0.713

15  Petroleum and products

 

 

0

16  Chemical manufacturing

 

 

0

17  Nonmetallic mineral products mfg.

 

 

18  Primary metals

 

 

0

19  Fabricated metals

 

 

0

20  Machinery manufacturing

 

 

0

21  Computer and electronic product

 

 

0

22  Electrical equipment

 

 

0

23  Aircraft and parts

 

 

0

24  Ship and boat building

 

 

0

25  Other transportation equipment

 

 

0

26  Furniture

 

 

0

27  Other manufacturing

 

 

0

28  Wholesale trade

 

 

0

29  Retail trade

7.463

1.161

8.624

30  Transportation and warehousing

6.145

1.817

7.961

31  Information